Our
Education section is an undiscovered gem. And it is
definitely not a
compilation of boring academic essays but a riveting look at the
serious
problems facing our education system. Take a moment to check it
out.
About Advertising
Click
Advertise Here for more details about our great advertising
rates.
IMPORTANT
NOTE
If running Norton Internet Security (NIS), please
temporarily disable it to enjoy the rich graphics of this
site.
Is My Son White
And Does it Even Matter?
By
Daniel Muniz
Even if my name was Dick Cheney, my skin color is brown
enough that nobody would have a problem identifying me as being
Hispanic. Likewise, my green-eyed blonde wife is easily identified
as white.
But what “label” does our infant son fall into? And does
it really matter?
And most importantly, who the hell should even care about it?
My little boy has a few of my features but in appearance, he has
most of my wife’s attributes. My hunch is that in 20 years from now,
people on the street would probably think that he is white instead
of Hispanic. But should it matter to him or to other people?
What really determines if he is classified as Hispanic or white? Or
is it even allowed to list both since that is perhaps the most
accurate designation?
And that is not to say that I want to naively ignore our cultural
and societal settings because even if some of them are absolutely
ridiculous, there are still so many people who have an emotional
investment in them. It is unfortunate but I still have to at least
be aware of them.
When Tiger Woods exploded on the professional golf scene, a number
of African-Americans expected him to articulate to the public how a
black man overcame the racial barriers in a practically all white
sport. Consequently, Tiger insisted that he did not consider himself
to be entirely black. Instead, he coined his own designation as “Cablinasian,”
which recognized the Caucasian, Black, Indian, and Asian elements of
himself.
The firestorm that resulted was immediate and intense.
Prominent minority leaders and organizations trashed him. Tiger was
roundly ridiculed and criticized, especially by people who felt that
he betrayed blacks. At best, he was described as uninformed and
naïve while at worst he was described using words that I will not
print here.
There are a growing number of Americans who just want to consider
themselves as that; American. Or perhaps in Tiger’s fashion, a
little bit of everything. My son is half Hispanic and half white. He
is not one or the other because he is both. So what is the use of
playing this “either/or” game of what you are?
As Tiger Woods stated on Oprah:
“I'm just who I am… whoever
you see in front of you.”
Idealistically, it shouldn’t matter how people are racially or
ethnically classified.
But for many in our modern paranoid culture, it does matter.
Tiger publicized a current in society that could someday produce
great waves. That is, racial and ethnic classifications really don’t
carry the kind of value that they once did. As a result, more
racially mixed people want to have such designations either
completely removed or at least be allowed to be included in more
than one category.
For now, perhaps the latter is the best approach. Recognizing all
the classifications is the most accurate and has the most meaning to
the people who belong to them as it does with Tiger and the growing
number of people who fall into multiple categories.
This development continues to stun and frighten many minority
leaders and organizations because they don’t want to see their
political strength diluted.
But most interestingly, of all places, America is the country where
the process of multiple classifications should evolve.
That’s not to say that the civil rights movement was useless. But
just the opposite in that the movement is achieving its ultimate
goal in arriving at a state where people shouldn’t care how you are
labeled or how you look. Times have changed and so have people.
When my mother was a little girl growing up in the barrio of a rural
South Texas community, she couldn’t even fathom that some day she
would have a grandson that would have come from a white woman.
Neither did she ever imagine that each of her future children would
some day marry white people. Or that a white man would actually live
in her house as in the case of my brother-in-law when he and my
sister stayed there for four months while their house was being
built.
The civil rights movement not only made such events possible but it
made them commonplace.
Perhaps the next step of its evolution is when racial and ethnic
classifications don’t even matter anymore. And perhaps far into the
future when my son becomes a grown man that can happen. Seeing the
firestorm that Tiger Woods ignited, it seems rather unlikely since
we do live in racially charged times. But then again, when my mother
was a little girl in a racially divided town, she never thought it
was remotely possible that she would ever have white in-laws or a
half white grandson.
We want your opinion! Tell us what you thought about
this article. Click the
Your Feedback menu item to send us
your comments.
COMMENTS FROM READERS
Coming from a German and Swedish background and
then my daughter with a Greek background added to that and then
my granddaughter with a Black background. I have always believed
we are American and American only. If we do not look at it as a
non hyphenated title then we need to include all the past
heritage. That would make my granddaughter be put into the
category of German, Swedish, Greek, Black American. That is why
we are "Americans only" This article was very good at pointing
out the reason we don't need labels and categories. Well written
and a good learning experience for my family.
-Sandra
If you are the Dick Cheney, I'd say your son
falls into the category of OOPS! Seriously? To me it doesn't
matter a persons color or nationality. I'm like Martin, it's the
content of one's character.
The Bible student should know that in Christ, there is neither
Jew nor Greek, male nor female, but we are all one in Christ
Jesus and that's the way I view this matter whether or not a
person is a Christian.
-unsigned
Man, your article caught my attention because
it sounded just like me and my green eyed white wife. I have
come to the point in my life that when I am asked, "White,
Hispanic, etc,,," that I don't mark anything. Since it is
illegal for any one organization to discriminate against me or
my children because of race, then my race to them is irrelevant.
If they [want to know] then I remind them of the law and
everyone will ignore that question. I believe if we are going to
stop this racial "pigeon-holing" then we need to quit answering
those questions and demand that we be judged upon our talents
and qualifications.
PS: I know exactly what your mother went through, I grew in
segregated S. Texas.
-Jeff
Who made up these racial designations in the
first place? And why?
-Keith
As a first generation American with a Mexican
father I find this article very interesting.
I am the lightest skinned child from my family and have light
eyes. I married a "white" man and our children are "white". But
even in my own extended family they think my children and even
myself are not Mexican; I initially only spoke Spanish and
learned English when I went to school.
I hate that I am forced to categorize my children. All the
documents say "white, of non-Spanish decent" or
"Hispanic"....nothing in-between.
I tell my kids check the box that says "Hispanic"....since this
is the game people want to play. I am waiting for my graduating
son to get questioned by his new college in the fall as to his
"true heritage".
I wondered if we had applied for a minority college scholarship
would they have actually given him the scholarship upon seeing
him? Or would he have been denied just because he has blonde
hair and blue eyes? -Gloria
Any opinions or views
expressed herein belong solely to the author and does not represent
any employer, organization, political party, governmental agency, or
any other entity and do not necessarily reflect the views of the
site owner or its participants.
Premium Ad
Announcements
Our
Miscellaneous section is our feature that covers offbeat
stories as well as our personal musings on just about anything.
Take a five minute break and check it out.